Semantical and Pragmatical Dimensions of Drchitectural Object: Towards Wittgensteinian Approach to the Architectural Studies
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.22394/2074-0492-2017-1-101-121Keywords:
architecture, interaction, sense, meaning, pragmatic understanding, semantic understanding, wittgensteinAbstract
This article suggests a development of sociological approach to the study of architectural objects basing on Wittgensteinian sociology. The first part of this text is devoted to a critique of explanatory models common to contemporary sociological studies of architecture. The criticism focuses on re-description and interpretation of architectural objects in terms of 'real social relations' standing behind them. This approach is said to be a result of "Enlightenment attitudes" inherited by contemporary sociological theory from classical projects. The principal aim of Enlightenment may be said to be as follows: discovering (and un-covering) hidden social structures that cannot be grasped by direct observation, nevertheless which stand behind and determine the flow of social life. The second part of the article is intended to develop an alternative research agenda. Referring to the works of Peter Winch, Ludwig Wittgenstein and Manchester school of ethnomethodology, I state that sociological study of architecture should abandon its preoccupation with investigating hidden causes and meanings of architectural objects which are determined by a wider social context. Instead sociologists have to focus on the study of ordinary acts which constitute meanings via the processes of everyday interactions. The latter approach is applied to the case-analysis of making sense of architectural objects at contemporary art festival 'Archstoyanie'.Downloads
References
Вахштайн В.С. (2015) Дело о повседневности. Социология в судебных прецедентах, М.; СПб: Центр гуманитарных инициатив.
Вебер М. (2002) Основные социологические понятия. Теоретическая социология: Антология. под ред. С.П. Баньковской, М.: Книжный дом «Университет».
Гарфинкель Г. (2011) Что такое этнометодология? Социологическое обозрение, 11 (3). Луман Н. (2002) «Что происходит?» и «Что за этим кроется?». Две социологии и теория общества. Теоретическая социология: Антология. под ред. С.П. Баньковской, М.: Книжный дом «Университет».
Райл Г. (1999) Понятие сознания, М.: Идея-Пресс, Дом интеллектуальной книги. Степанцов П. М. (2008) Нет такой вещи, как социальная наука: в защиту Питера Уинча. Размышления над книгой. Социологическое обозрение, 7 (2).
Степанцов П.М. (2013) Социальное действие между интерпретацией и пониманием. Социология власти, 1-2 (27-56).
Степанцов П.М. (2015) Теоретические стратегии исследования социального действия: каузальное объяснение vs понимание смысла. Социология власти, 4.
Уинч П. (1996) Идея социальной науки и ее отношение к философии, М.: Русское феноменологическое общество.
Филиппов А. Ф. (2009) От социологического просвещения к социальному действию. Пути России. Современное интеллектуальное пространство, под ред. М.Г. Пугачевой, В.С. Вахштайна. Т. XVI, М.: Университетская книга: 263-270. Giddens A. (1995) A contemporary critique of historical materialism. 2nd ed., Stanford University Press, CA.
Jones P. (2006) The Sociology of Architecture and the Politics of Building: The Discursive Construction of Ground Zero. Sociology, 40 (3): 549-565.
Jones P. (2011) The Sociology of Architecture: Constructing Identities, Liverpool, UK: Liverpool University Press.
Hutchinson P, Read R, Sharrock W. (2008). There is no such Thing as a Social Science: in defense of Peter Winch. Ashgate Publishing Limited.
Ramsey S.C. (1987) Some sociological aspects of Modern Architecture. The Sociological Review, 22 (4).
Spencer C. (2005) Designing the person: sociological assumptions embodied within the architecture of Charles Rennie Mackintosh and Le Corbusier. Irish Journal of Sociology, 14 (1): 141-162.
Uebel T. (2012) Narratives and Action Explanation. Philosophy of the Social Sciences, 42: 31-67.
Wittgenstein L. (2006) Philosophical Investigation, Oxford: Blackwell Publishing.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
How to Cite
Коды статьи
- EDN YPKVSG
- Тип статьи (РИНЦ) Научная статья (Научная статья)